Back Hide Notes
Letters between Bruno Bauer and Edgar Bauer

1840-02-04. Bruno to Edgar, from Bonn

English machine

Author: Bruno Bauer  Year: 1843 

40 That the collision between the State and the Roman Church in fact goes so far, and that the demands on which the Archbishop insists are grounded in a principle whose recognition the State, when it took over the provinces here, promised, one will in Berlin admittedly not confess to oneself, because one harbours anxieties for the religious interest itself, whose consistent and extreme assertion one fears in the Archbishop and his conduct. One dare not let it come to an open struggle with him, because one needs him for oneself. Hence this whole theological form of the struggle hitherto. Hence the idea of using the Hermesians for the struggle against the supposed pretensions of the Archbishop — the Hermesians, who are Catholic enough to prove all Roman dogmas with the help of Kantian enlightenment, enlightened and timid enough to appeal in the most important matters, concerning faith and its ground, from the Pope to the State, and so Roman that they again ascribe infallibility to the Pope in accidental matters as well as in the entanglements of the Church with the world. In regard to mixed marriages, no one has declared for the government, and they cannot declare themselves against the deeply grounded Roman principle. The true reason why the Roman claims were not sharply scrutinised, why the true struggle with them was not possible and could not be permitted, now comes ever more to light. The State must take a religious interest in itself and restrict the further development of philosophy. Hitherto it had been, through its connection with the State, bound in solidarity, hence also constrained; it had, since it was apparently left free and was favoured besides, i.e., participated in the advantages of the government, set its own limit. But as it is fettered, it is driven beyond all fetters and limits. The fettered Prometheus was as such freer than when he still went about freely and taught men to sacrifice.
[Notes for 40 here]
41 The true reason why the Roman claims were not sharply scrutinised, why the true struggle with them was not possible and could not be permitted, now comes ever more to light. The State must take a religious interest in itself and restrict the further development of philosophy. Hitherto it had been, through its connection with the State, bound in solidarity, hence also constrained; it had, since it was apparently left free and was favoured besides, i.e., participated in the advantages of the government, set its own limit. But as it is fettered, it is driven beyond all fetters and limits. The fettered Prometheus was as such freer than when he still went about freely and taught men to sacrifice.
[Notes for 41 here]
42 The free Prometheus was, as is well known, a sophist in his doctrine of sacrifice, but in the pain of his fetters he was exalted above all powers.
[Notes for 42 here]
43 In that science is cast out, it is left to itself. One no longer wants it, good! so it is emancipated and I too am free, insofar as I serve the outcast. I have never felt so happy, so free.....
[Notes for 43 here]
44 Nor can you choose the university career. Vestigia terrent. With me it is something different: I must once work my way through the cave. When one — quite apart from external cares of life — feels oneself uncertain, it is only a share in the vibration of the general uncertainty which has seized all parties, but in the striving one only a momentary pain, the pain of struggling freedom: the victory will not fail to appear. What the others will do, who now think to triumph over the downfall of science, will show itself in the end..... Bonn, 4th February Bruno. 1840.
[Notes for 44 here]
45 Bonn, 4th February 1840. Bruno
[Notes for 45 here]
⬅ 1840-01-20. Bruno to Edgar, from Bonn 1840-01-29. Edgar to Bruno, from Berlin ➡