Hide Notes
⬅ Back

V. “Critical Criticism” As a Mystery-Monger, Or “Critical Criticism” As Herr Szeliga

The World System of the Mysteries of Paris

English MIA

Author: Karl Marx  Year: 1845 

§432 "This world of mysteries is now the general world system, in which the individual action of the Mysteries of Paris is set."
[Notes for §432 here]
§433 Before, "however", Herr Szeliga "passes on to the philosophical reproduction of the epic event", he must "assemble in a general picture the sketches previously jotted down separately".
[Notes for §433 here]
§434 It must be considered as a real confession, a revelation of Herr Szeliga's Critical Mystery, when he says that he wishes to pass ou to the "philosophical reproduction" of the epic event. He has so far been "philosophically reproducing" the world system.
[Notes for §434 here]
§435 Herr Szeliga continues his confession:
[Notes for §435 here]
§436 "From our presentation it appears that the individual mysteries dealt with have not their value in themselves, each separate from the others, and are in no way magnificent novelties for gossip, but that their value consists in their constituting an organically linked sequence, the totality of which is "Mystery".
[Notes for §436 here]
§437 In his mood of sincerity, Herr Szeliga goes still further. He admits that the "speculative sequence" is not the real sequence of the Mysteres de Paris.
[Notes for §437 here]
§438 "Granted, the mysteries do not appear in our epic in the relationship of this self-knowing sequence" (to cost prices?). "But we are not dealing with the logical, obvious, free organism of criticism, but with a mysterious vegetable existence."
[Notes for §438 here]
§439 We shall pass over Herr Szeliga's summary and go on immediately to the point that constitutes the "transition". In Pipelet we saw the "self-mockery of Mystery".
[Notes for §439 here]
§440 "In self-mockery, Mystery passes judgment on itself. Thereby the mysteries, annihilating themselves in their final consequence, challenge every strong character to independent examination."
[Notes for §440 here]
§441 Rudolph, Prince of Geroldstein, the man of "pure Criticism”, is destined to carry out this examination and the "disclosure of the mysteries."
[Notes for §441 here]
§442 If we deal with Rudolph and his deeds only later, after diverting our attention from Herr Szeliga for some time, it can already be foreseen, and to a certain degree the reader can sense, indeed even surmise without presumption, that instead of treating him as a "mysterious vegetable existence”, which he is in the Critical Literatur-Zeitung, we shall make him a "logical, obvious, free link" in the "organism of Critical Criticism."
[Notes for §442 here]
⬅ Polite Society A mockery ➡